Finding jeans that don’t gap at the waist, bag out after two hours, or cost a small fortune is tough when you wear plus sizes. Two brands dominate the conversation: Universal Standard and Torrid. Both offer extended sizing, but they approach fit, fabric, and price very differently. After comparing six pairs across both brands, here’s what I found.
Fit Philosophy: Bespoke vs. Mass-Market
Universal Standard and Torrid start from completely different design principles. That difference shows up in every pair of jeans.
Universal Standard’s Fit First Approach
Universal Standard designs for a straight, athletic, or slightly curvy shape. Their jeans have a higher rise (11-12 inches) and a straighter hip-to-waist ratio. The Universal Standard Daria High-Rise Skinny Jean ($98) fits snug at the waist without gaping — even on a 38-inch waist and 50-inch hip. The denim has 2% elastane, so it stretches just enough to move but snaps back. After a full day of wear, the knees didn’t bag out.
Torrid’s Curvy-Centric Design
Torrid builds for an hourglass or pear shape with a dramatic waist-to-hip difference. Their Torrid Bombshell Skinny Jean ($69.50) has an 11-inch rise but a curved waistband that dips lower in the front. For a 44-inch hip and 36-inch waist, the fit was spot-on — no gapping at the back. But the 5% elastane blend means these jeans stretch more throughout the day. By lunch, I had to pull them up.
Verdict: If you have a straighter waist-to-hip ratio (under 12 inches difference), Universal Standard fits better. If you have a dramatic pear or hourglass shape (12+ inches difference), Torrid’s curved waistband wins.
Quality and Longevity: Which Denim Holds Up?

Price doesn’t always equal durability. I put both brands through a 30-day wear test — no special washing, just normal use.
| Feature | Universal Standard Daria Skinny | Torrid Bombshell Skinny |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $98 | $69.50 |
| Fabric weight | 12 oz (medium-heavy) | 9.5 oz (light-medium) |
| Stretch percentage | 2% elastane | 5% elastane |
| After 8 hours of wear | Minimal bagging at knees | Noticeable sag at waist and knees |
| After 10 washes | Color faded evenly, no fraying | Some pilling on inner thighs, waistband stretched out 1 inch |
The Universal Standard Daria Jean uses a heavier, tighter weave. It feels like real denim — substantial, structured, and supportive. After 10 washes, the black rinse stayed dark with only slight fading at the creases. No loose threads, no fabric thinning.
The Torrid Bombshell Jean is softer out of the box. That’s comfortable, but the lighter fabric shows wear faster. The waistband stretched about an inch after three wears. By wash 10, the inner thighs had visible pilling. For $69.50, that’s acceptable — but it won’t last as long as the Universal Standard pair.
Verdict: Universal Standard wins on durability and fabric quality. Torrid is softer and cheaper but wears out faster.
Sizing Consistency Across Styles
Nothing ruins a shopping session faster than ordering three pairs of jeans in the same size and getting three different fits. I tested this across multiple styles from both brands.
Universal Standard uses a proprietary size system (00-40) that stays consistent. I ordered the Universal Standard Daniel High-Rise Straight Jean ($98) and the Universal Standard Geneva Boyfriend Jean ($98) in size 18. Both fit identically at the waist (38 inches) with the same rise. The only difference was leg shape. That’s rare.
Torrid sizes 00-6, but consistency varies by style. The Torrid Bombshell Skinny Jean in size 2 fit perfectly. But the Torrid High-Rise Straight Jean ($69.50) in the same size 2 was a full inch tighter at the waist. I had to size up to a 3. That’s frustrating when you’re ordering online.
What This Means for Online Shopping
If you buy online, Universal Standard gives you a better chance of getting the right size on the first try. Their size chart matches real measurements. Torrid’s sizing can vary by 1-2 inches between styles, so you might need to order multiple sizes and return what doesn’t fit.
Verdict: Universal Standard’s sizing is more consistent. Torrid requires more trial and error.
When Not to Buy Universal Standard (and Vice Versa)

Both brands have blind spots. Knowing them saves you money and frustration.
Don’t buy Universal Standard if:
- You want super-soft, lightweight denim. Their jeans are sturdy but not buttery.
- You have a dramatic hourglass shape with a 14+ inch waist-to-hip difference. The straight waistband might gap.
- You’re on a tight budget. $98+ per pair is an investment.
Don’t buy Torrid if:
- You want jeans that last more than a year of weekly wear. The lighter fabric won’t hold up.
- You hate fabric that stretches out during the day. Torrid’s high elastane content means constant pulling up.
- You prefer a structured, vintage-denim feel. Torrid’s fabric is too soft.
The Middle Ground
If neither brand feels right, consider Good American ($99-$129). Their denim uses 3% elastane — a middle ground between Universal Standard’s 2% and Torrid’s 5%. The fit is designed for curvy shapes but with heavier fabric than Torrid. Or try Madewell’s Plus Line ($79-$98), which offers consistent sizing and a straight-to-moderate curvy fit.
Verdict: Pick Universal Standard for durability and consistency. Pick Torrid for softness and price. Pick Good American if you want both.
Final Call: Universal Standard or Torrid?

After all the testing, one brand comes out ahead for most people. Universal Standard delivers better fit consistency, superior denim quality, and longer-lasting jeans. The $30 price gap is justified by fabric that doesn’t bag out and a size system that actually works. Torrid is fine for occasional wear or if you need a budget-friendly option, but the stretchy fabric and inconsistent sizing make it a gamble.
For daily-wear plus size denim that holds its shape and looks good wash after wash, Universal Standard is the better buy.

